Information for "SunanAbuDawoud-017-001-26358"

Narrated Abdullah Ibn Abbas: The Messenger of Allah ﷺ used to prostrate and sleep in prostration and produce puffing sounds during sleep. Then he would stand and pray and would not perform ablution. I said to him: you prayed but did not perform ablution though you slept in prostration. He replied: Ablution is necessary for one who sleeps while he is lying down. Uthman and Hannad added: For when he lies down; his joints are relaxed.Abu Dawud said: The statement ablution is necessary for one who sleeps while one is lying down is a munkar rejected tradition. It has been narrated only by Yazid Abu Khalid AlDalani; on the authority of Qatadah. And its earlier part has been narrated by a group of narrators from Ibn Abbas; they did not mention anything about it. He Ibn Abbas said: The Prophet ﷺ was protected during his sleep. Aisha reported: The Prophet ﷺ said: My eyes sleep; but my heart does not sleep. Shubah said: Qatadah heard from Ab AlAliyah only four traditions: the tradition about Jonah son of Matthew; the tradition reported by Ibn Umar about prayer; the tradition stating that the judges are three; and the tradition narrated by Ibn Abbas saying: This tradition has been narrated to me by reliable persons ; Umar is one of them; and the most reliable of them in my opinion is Umar. Abu Dawud said: I asked Ahmad Bin Hanbal about the tradition narrated by Yazid AlDalani. He rebuked me out of respect for him. Then he said: Yazid AlDalani does not add anything to what has been narrated by the teachers of Qatadah. He did not care of this tradition due to its weakness.