Different Takaful Business models by Zainal Kassim
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you 1st November 2007
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space.
Different Takaful Business
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
Delete key
Model in Practice
- Concept and Modalities
Zainal Abidin Mohd. Kassim, FIA
Langham Hotel, London
www.mercer.com
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space. Why not Insurance?
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
Delete key
Why conventional insurance is not Sharia compliant
From the insured perspective
– Insurance is a (pure) risk transfer mechanism, the insured loss is
restricted to his premium
– Insurance companies investments are not in Sharia compliant
assets (e.g. interest bearing bonds, investments in prohibited
businesses)
– Certain insurance products may lack transparency (e.g. how much
is the insurer charging for managing the policy is not known to the
policyholder)
From the (insurance) investors perspective
– Underwriting profits are subject to an element of chance
(speculative risk)
– Investments are not Sharia compliant
Mercer 2
Basis of operation of a conventional General Insurance company
There is typically no identifiable policyholders fund
Premiums once paid becomes part of the assets of the company. The
company in turn becomes liable to pay all insured claims arising
All investment income on these assets and any underwriting surplus or
losses accrue to the shareholders of the company
Policyholders typically do not know how much of his premium goes
towards claims, expenses and profit to the company
Only restrictions on investments relate to the Asset Liability
Management constraints imposed by management and/or Regulators
Mercer 3
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space. Takaful - The building blocks
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
Delete key
What enabled the establishment of Takaful?
The Islamic Fiqh (Muslim Jurisprudence) Academy under the auspices of the
Organization of Islamic Conference ruled in 1985 that : “Insurance through the
concept of a cooperative (founded on the basis of Tabarru’) is acceptable in
Islam”
This is the basis of modern Islamic Insurance where the insured is also the insurer
(risk sharing rather than risk transfer) and Gharar is overcome through
premiums being Tabarru’.
Mercer 5
The Takaful Fund - Risk
Gharar (uncertainty) is present in any insurance type arrangement. When you buy
an insurance policy you may or may not claim from the insurer depending on
whether the insured event transpired or not during the duration of the policy.
Premiums are donated to the Takaful Risk Fund by the participants or
policyholders. Tabarru’ is a sharia approved gratuitous contract, which by its nature
accommodates Gharar.
Mercer 6
Islamic Contracts of Compensation
(sample)
Partnership between capital providers.
Musharaka Profit, shared in an agreed percentage
(e.g. Joint stock companies)
Partnership between capital provider
and entrepreneur. The former brings
capital, the latter brings
Mudharaba expertise/effort. Profit is shared in
CAPITAL agreed percentages. Losses accrue
to capital provider only.
Entrepreneur bears his own expenses.
Entrepreneur given a fixed fee for this
expertise/effort. Does not share in
Wakala profit or loss which accrues to the
capital provider. Entrepreneur bears
his own expenses.
Mercer 7
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space. Sudan’s Takaful Model
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
Delete key
Basis of Operation – the Cooperative model
Set up as a cooperative but with a small shareholders fund to meet statutory
requirements. Premiums are deemed to be tabarru’.
All expenses (including management and acquisition costs) are met by the cooperative
fund
All surpluses belong to the policyholders, shareholders returns are restricted to the
investment income on the shareholders fund.
If the shareholders sets up a separate management structure for investing the assets of
the cooperative fund, the shareholders will be entitled to a share of the investment
profits. Investment management expenses are not charged to the cooperative fund.
Effectively the investment services are contracted out by the policyholders on the basis
of the mudharabah contract.
Policyholders are represented on the Board of Directors of the company.
There is a Sharia Supervisory Board responsible for ensuring the company’s operation
complies with Sharia law.
Mercer 9
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space. Malaysia’s Takaful Model
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
Delete key
Basis of Operation - the Company / Cooperative approach
The Mudharabah model
The first Takaful Operator in Malaysia is Syarikat Takaful Malaysia. It has a separately
identified shareholders and policyholders (Takaful) fund. It follows the Mudharabah
model on the basis of the following interpretation of the insurance process;
– The policyholders are designated as the capital providers to the Takaful Fund
– The shareholders are designated as the entrepreneur whose tasks is managing the
Takaful Fund
– Surplus arising in the Takaful Fund arises from both the underwriting of risk and the
investment of assets and is shared on a pre agreed profit sharing percentage
(normally 50:50 for non life operation). All management expenses are met entirely
by the shareholders fund. However, all deficits in the Takaful fund accrue to the
policyholders only, not the shareholders.
Mercer 11
Basis of Operation - the Company / Cooperative approach
The Wakala/Mudharabah model
The later Takaful Operators opted for the Wakala Model for the underwriting portion of
the operation. Under the wakala contract;
– The Operator takes a fee expressed as a percentage of the premium. This premium
net of the fee is then deposited in the Takaful Fund from which claims are paid.
– In return for the fee, all management and distribution costs are met by the
shareholders fund.
– Underwriting surplus and deficits accrue to the policyholders
– Some Takaful Operators take a share of the underwriting surplus as an “incentive”
wakala fee while not sharing in the underwriting losses
Concurrently the Takaful Operators opted for the Mudharabah Model for the investment
portion of the operation;
– The Operator takes a percentage share of the investment income but does not
share in investment losses
– All investment management expenses are borne by the shareholders fund
For unit linked type of Takaful Life (called “Family”) products the Takaful Operator may
choose the Wakala model where they take a percentage of the NAV under investment
as their fee instead of Mudharabah profit share model
There are no policyholders representatives on the Board of Director.
Mercer 12
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space. Indonesia’s Takaful Model
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
Delete key
Basis of Operation – The Takaful Window
Apart from two companies, all the other takaful operations in Indonesia
are “window” based operation.
Under a window operation a notional takaful fund is set up within the
conventional insurance fund. Assets are ring fenced within this
notional fund and consists of only sharia approved investments.
It is notional in that there is no legal separation of assets and in any
winding up it is doubtful that the assets in the takaful window is
provided any protection from the liability of the other (conventional)
policyholders
The dominant Takaful Model in Indonesia is the Mudharabah model for
both underwriting and investment business within the takaful
operation. However, notwithstanding this model there is provision to
treat commissions as a first charge on takaful premiums
There are no policyholders representatives on the Board of Directors
Mercer 14
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space. The Middle East’s Takaful
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
Model
Delete key
Basis of Operation – Islamic Contracts for Takaful
The Wakala and the Mudharabah contracts are the choice contracts
for Takaful in the Middle East. With some exceptions the Mudharabah
contract is solely used only for investments of Takaful Funds
There is a particularly unique form of the wakala contract practiced by
many Takaful Operators in the Middle East;
– Instead of stating the wakala fee explicitly in each takaful contract,
the wakala fee is announced (usually through the printed press) at
the beginning of each financial year of the Takaful Operator and is
fixed for the duration of the year
Underwriting surplus, if provided as an incentive fee for the Takaful
Operator under the wakala contract, starts at a higher threshold rather
than the first dollar of surplus as in Malaysia
There are no policyholder representatives on the Board of Directors
Mercer 16
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space. The Pakistan’s Takaful Model
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
Delete key
Basis of Operation – Wakala with Waqf
While the wakala contract still applies between the Takaful Operator
and the Takaful Fund, Pakistan’s Shariah Scholars raised certain
issues with the accompanying Tabarru’ contributions which is
considered as a conditional gift;
– As a conditional gift, the contributions are specifically to be used to
pay claims with any underwriting surplus still accruing to the
Tabarru’ contributors. Under this assumption there is a concern that
the transaction has the characteristic of a contract of compensation.
Under such conditions the underlying gharar would have
invalidated the transaction under Sharia law. There is also the issue
of the fairness of intergenerational subsidies between different
generations of participants if such ownership links prevails.
– To avoid such doubts, the Sharia proposed the use of an Islamic
Trust Fund, a waqf.
– Under a waqf the any lingering ownership by the policyholders to
the Tabarru’ contribution is legally severed
Mercer 18
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space. Takaful – Towards a viable
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
Business Model
Delete key
Role of Capital
Although risks are retained within the Takaful Funds, a mechanism is required to
smooth out the expected claims fluctuations
Under the Sudan Model there is explicit provision for policyholders to contribute
additional premiums should a deficit occur. However, this is not usually done in
practice. No such provision exist elsewhere.
Typically, funding of these volatilities comes first through utilization of reserves built
from past surpluses and next from loans made from the shareholders funds. These
can be seen as subordinated interest free loans (Qard Hasan)
Loans to be repaid (and are a first charge) from future Takaful surpluses
Mercer 20
ReTakaful
The need for Qard can be minimized through appropriate retakaful arrangements.
Retakaful is different from reinsurance in that;
– The reinsured is not the TO but instead it is the Takaful Risk Fund
– The TO acts as the agent to the Takaful Risk Fund to secure the necessary
retakaful programs
– While reinsurance acts to spread the volatility of the insurer over time, retakaful
is more akin to a risk pool at a specific time
Mercer 21
The Challenges for a viable Takaful business model
Mudharabah model likely to be limited to investment rather than the
underwriting process in Takaful
Regulators interpretation of the role of stakeholders and role of capital
General (Casualty) Takaful
– Easily adaptable for personal lines (high volume with low volatility)
– Problems of capacity for commercial lines (high volatility) without
sufficient Retakaful support
– Lack of suitable Sharia compliant assets
Life (Family) Takaful
– Apart for in Malaysia, Family Takaful is still underdeveloped
elsewhere
– What constitute an acceptable Family Takaful product?
– Limited availability of Sharia compliant asset classes imposes a
limitation on product innovation
Mercer 22
Delete this text box to
display the color square; you
may also insert an image or
client logo in this space. Takaful – The primary target
To delete the text box, click within
text, hit the Esc key and then the
market
Delete key
The Muslim Population
1.84 billion worldwide in 2007
1.24 billion in Asia (including Middle East)
490.9 million in Africa
50.7 million in Europe
Muslim population is increasing at a rate of 2% p.a. around the world.
Source: www.islamicpopulation.com
Mercer 24
Muslims make up 1.84 billion of the world’s population
Mercer 25
Potential Takaful Market by Region
Taking into account the likely penetration among Muslims, adjustments for non-Muslim potential,
there is worldwide Takaful premium potential of at least US$ 20 billion annually, compared to
current figure of US$ 4 billion*
*Source: Oliver Wyman in their publication “Takaful: A new global insurance growth opportunity”
Mercer 26
Zainal Kassim Simon Grout
Suite 17.02 Kenanga International 1 Neal Street
Jalan Sultan Ismail London
50490 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia WC2H 9QL England
zainal.kassim@mercer.com simon.grout@oliverwyman.com www.mercer.com
